Humility and medical guidelines

We have LOTS of guidelines and recommendations. We could use LOTS more humility.

The Advisory Committee for Immunization Practices (ACIP) issued a recommendation in September of 2014 that pneumococcal vaccine naive individuals 65 and over get a Prevnar13 followed by a Pneumovax 6-12 months later, and that those who have had a Pneumovax get a Prevnar13 a minimum of 12 months after their Pneumovax.

As a result of this recommendation, institutions are setting up protocols and adjusting their immunization forms and metrics to conform to this new 'standard' and clinicians have started telling patients they are 'due' for the new immunization. (This is true where I work, and I experienced it recently with a relative being seen at the Geriatric Clinic of the Massachusetts General Hospital.)

Austin Frakt and Aaron Carroll  wrote recently about how inaccurate the perceptions of patients are when it comes to risks and benefits. (I think clinicians are not much more accurate, sad to say.) One reason is the automatic cascade from limited evidence, to guidelines, and then to clinical practice work flows that get presented to patients without nuance or ambiguity. Instead of "We have some evidence that suggests..." the approach too often is "You are due for..." or "The treatment is..."  It is worth stepping back a moment to ask ourselves: "How sure are we? What does the data actually say?"

In the instance of Prevnar13, the evidence underlying the recommendation is actually quite limited:

  • There are 2 published studies of immunogenicity of the vaccine. These show that Prevnar13 causes a more robust antibody response in the short term (4 months) and medium term (4 years), compared to the PPSV23 (Pneumovax). Interesting and suggestive, but not proof of benefit.
  • There is one unpublished randomized clinical trial (done by Pfizer, the manufacturer of the vaccine) involving 85,000 community dwelling adults over 65 in the Netherlands (CAPITA) which shows that 1 invasive serious illness like meningitis or sepsis (IPD) is prevented for every 27,800 adults vaccinated with Prevnar13 and 1 hospitalization for community acquire pneumonia (CAP) is prevented for every 1620 adults vaccinated with Prevnar13. 

Based on this, a review in JAMA (2/17/2015) notes that the impact of the vaccine 'can only be inferred' at this point.

Perhaps we should not be telling patients they are due for a vaccine or incentivizing clinicians to pressure them to have it. Instead we should be saying that, based on fairly limited evidence, it appears that we have an improved vaccine that will protect 1 in 27,000 from a potentially lethal infection and 1 in 1600 from a hospitalization for pneumonia. 

Shared decision making means helping patients make autonomous choices based on current best evidence and personal values and preferences. We should be incentivizing clinicians to offer patients appropriate and balanced information about benefits and risks, not incentivizing clinicians based on whether or not the patient wants accepts the values and goals of the institution, an insurance company, a panel of experts, or CMS.


 

Topic:

Comments

I think the wind vitality will be a substantial scale stage for delivering power in future. There are great deals of winds plants are as of now thrived over the world University Assignment Help. Much obliged to you for sharing this data and continues sharing such matters.

Persistent populaces over the world are ending up plainly progressively assorted, presenting an assortment of wellbeing practices that are impacted by a patient's social foundation Expert assignment writers Tomorrow's Doctors rules express that every single qualified specialist must regard patients 'without partiality', independent of 'differing qualities of foundation and opportunity, dialect, culture and lifestyle'. Are therapeutic understudies at present being completely upheld to procure this key aptitude?

First, what an incredible fascination and collection you have! I can imagine how many real-life stories you have already read through these old letters. australia assignment writing Anyway, thanks for sharing this. It's pretty awesome to see how fanboying/fangirlinng was like in the early years and how sweet of Mr.Train to respond to every request. I'm sure it had cost him postage, so I really think of it as a swell move.

Persistent populaces in the world ended with a clear progressive classification dissertation writing service uk, presented by various good practices, affected by the social basis of the patient.

Perhaps we should not be telling patients they are due for a vaccine or incentivizing clinicians to pressure them to have it.
Send Flowers To Japan

Medicine has evolved a lot in the past few years and for that we should be thankful, because many people have lost their lives in the past due to diseases that now can be prevented with vaccines. Besides vaccines, the advanced medical imaging in Toms River NJ can offer valuable information regarding our health status at any given moment. Health is the most important, that's why we should always follow the doctor's orders.

IUI Treatment IVI is a global leader in assisted fertility treatment, with more than 2000 health professionals providing care across over 50 clinics in 11 countries worldwide

Determined masses on the planet finished with a reasonable dynamic grouping Dissertation Writing Service UK, introduced by different great practices, influenced by the social premise of the patient.

To start with, what a unimaginable interest and gathering you have! I can envision what number of genuine stories you have just perused these old letters. Dissertation Help Online Anyway, a debt of gratitude is in order for sharing this. It's really great to perceive how fanboying/fangirlinng resembled in the early years and how sweet of Mr.Train to react to each demand. I'm certain it had taken a toll him postage, so I truly consider it a swell move.

Tenacious peoples over the world are winding up doubtlessly dynamically various, introducing a collection of prosperity rehearses that are affected by a patient's social establishment Dissertation Help UK Tomorrow's Doctors decides express that each and every qualified master must respect patients 'without prejudice', free of 'varying characteristics of establishment and opportunity, lingo, culture and way of life'. Are helpful understudies at exhibit being totally maintained to get this key fitness?

Wonderful, what a weblog it is! This website presents helpful information to us, keep it up. Send Gifts To pakistan

I would like to quote the S2 guideline: S2 guideline: Diagnosis and therapy of venous thrombosis and pulmonary embolism. Unfortunately, I am unsure of the correct entry in the final score.
Can you help me?

Thanks in advance.
Hire someone to do assignment

They quote according to the respective publication type. Particularly in the case of Internet publications, the correct indication of the version must be observed.
best consulting firms

BlackMen's picture

I'm happy to see the immense subtle element here!. cccam server

Bergara green beltIn this experiment, children and small detectives go on the trail of animal and vegetable fats. someone write my research paper They learn that fats and oils are among the basic nutrients of humans and foods have a different fat content.

Hire Our Professional Cheap Dissertation Writing Service Now Because Our Low-Priced Packages can Save Your Pocket Budget… Guaranteed ! custom dissertation

BlackMen's picture

Also, you have no stems what a hit songs is so you think thousands of rap instrumentals have it online. DonBeats are 6 in a million of cheap beats. You keep telling yourself it's about exclusive beats you know, that's a nice way of taking no responsibility for your rap instrumentals. At sometime a lot of online websites for beats got their neumann u87 on the genre and implemented into their own studio and that's how we got it.

Modesty is the nature of being unassuming. Lowliness as a low self-respect and feeling of unworthiness In a religious setting this can mean an acknowledgment of self in connection to God or divinities, and self-corruption with consequent accommodation to said god as an individual from that religion. Ansel Elgort Blue Jacket

BlackMen's picture

I can see that you are an expert at your field! I am launching a website soon, and your information will be very useful for me.. Thanks for all your help and wishing you all the success in your business. gift ideas

Your post so inspirative and great point, Medical Oncology solution uses the most up-to-date evidence based clinical guidelines, This is definitely an fantastic online site. Axion laminate flooring at wisefloors

BlackMen's picture

Also, you have no stems what a hit songs is so you think thousands of rap instrumentals have it online. DonBeats are 6 in a million of cheap beats. You keep telling yourself it's about exclusive beats you know, that's a nice way of taking no responsibility for your rap instrumentals. At sometime a lot of online websites for beats got their neumann u87 on the genre and implemented into their own studio and that's how we got it.

Pleasant to be going by your web journal once more, it has been months for me. Well this article i've been sat tight for so long. I require this article to finish my task in the school, and it has same theme with your article. Much obliged, incredible offer. Profile Backlinks

The data you have posted is exceptionally valuable. The locales you have alluded was great. A debt of gratitude is in order for sharing.. Bellevue garage doors

It is amazing topic in my eyes and author have good command on this topic through which he makes it easy for the readers

Wonder Woman Jacket

I am extremely delighted in for this online journal. Its an educational subject. It help me all that much to take care of a few issues. Its chance are so incredible and working style so fast. Whitsundays Builder

Astounding .. Astonishing .. I'll bookmark your web journal and take the bolsters additionally… I'm upbeat to discover such a large number of valuable information here in the post, we require work out more methods in such manner, a debt of gratitude is in order for sharing. autoradio gps 2017 website page